Site   Web

April 25, 2011

How The Current Sales Tax War Involving Amazon May Affect All Ecommerce Websites

ecommerce

Amazon.com and big box retailers such as Wal-Mart and Target are locked in an all-out war over the collection of sales taxes. And cash-strapped states are also backing changes in sales tax laws in more than a dozen states.

While small ecommerce websites are relegated to observe the struggle from the sidelines, the impact of these changes on them could be huge.

Background – Sales Taxes v. Use Taxes

For starters, regarding sales taxes, the general rule is that a state may tax goods sold within its borders to the extent permitted under the U.S. Constitution. Sales taxes are collected by sellers on the sale of tangible property within the seller’s state. So, for example, a consumer in California who buys a widget from a local retailer pays a sales tax that is collected by the retailer.

Use taxes compliment a state’s sales tax and are imposed so that a consumer would theoretically have nothing to gain by shopping out-of-state. It works like this: in the above example, if the consumer purchases the widget out-of-state (say from online retailer in New York), he/she would be liable to pay a use tax on the purchase at the same tax rate as if the purchase had been from a California retailer.

The catch is that while sales taxes are mandated to be collected by retailers, use taxes are imposed directly on consumers, and most do not report and pay a use tax on out-of-state purchases. The result: states lose significant tax revenues on out-of-state purchases of tangible goods. Because individuals generally fail to pay use taxes, states have sought to find ways to impose a sales tax collection burden on the out-of-state retailer.

In 1992, the US Supreme Court ruled that states could only require out-of-state retailers to collect a sales tax if they have a “nexus” (i.e. a physical presence) in the state. The Supreme Court reasoned that the current patchwork of approximately 7,500 taxing jurisdictions in the United States is so complex that it would place an unreasonable burden on out-of-state retailers to charge and collect sales taxes.

Should Online Retailers Have to Charge Sales Tax?

The current battle focuses on what constitutes “nexus”, which the big box retailers and various states want to expand from a merely a physical presence in a state to states in which a website has marketing affiliates (even though they do not have a physical presence).

One example is Illinois which recently passed a new law that requires an out of state retailer to collect sales tax if it employs marketing affiliates in Illinois. Amazon retaliated by reportedly terminating approximately 9,000 affiliates to avoid collection of sales taxes in Illinois, just as Amazon had done previously when Hawaii, North Carolina and Rhode Island passed similar legislation.

Following Amazon’s termination of its Illinois affiliates, it’s been reported that Wal-Mart and other big box retailers offered to work with the terminated Amazon affiliates. This action has led to Amazon’s claim that the real reason for the tax law changes is to allow big box retailers to poach its affiliates.

States reply that it’s just a question of “fairness.” Why put brick and mortar businesses at a competitive disadvantage?

Conclusion

For small ecommerce companies watching from the sidelines, the potential effect of the current trend in state sales tax laws could be huge in terms of the cost to comply.

Moreover, one of the key reasons for the explosion of entrepreneurial activity on the Web is that there’s a relatively low barrier to entry. If these laws become universal, many start-up entrepreneurs may simply conclude that it’s really not worth the hassle.


Leading SaaS lawyer Chip Cooper has automated the process of drafting website legal forms. Use his free online tool — Website Contracts Determinator — to determine which documents your website really needs. Discover how quick, easy, and cost-effective it is to draft your website legal forms at DigiContracts.com.

3 Responses to “How The Current Sales Tax War Involving Amazon May Affect All Ecommerce Websites

    avatar Zippy Cart says:

    “Fairness?” There’s no “fair” in business. Every company just does whatever it has to in order to survive. If we are going to get really technical about fairness, then why not say that online retailers should pay sales tax on sales to the state where the purchaser lives? Why should online retailers have an “unfair” advantage in being able to sell tax free? All companies, large and small, are trying to get the best deal that they can, that’s why we have offshoring of jobs and overseas manufacturing.

    avatar Dydacomp says:

    One good thing for small eCommerce businesses is many solutions have the option to add online sales tax to their shopping cart, Like we offer at Dydacomp. The online sales tax is a very important issue that many people are all watching from the sidelines waiting to see the governments next move. One thing is clear there must be a clearer set of guidelines for sales tax as there can be many loopholes.

    Thanks for sharing!

    Molly Griffin

    avatar Bill Platt says:

    As I see it currently, the only solution I see is the Feds stepping in to provide a Federal framework enabling businesses to collect taxes based on the location of the buyer, not the seller or affiliate.

    The Feds should provide a platform for individual business owners to go to one place, and have IPN access to the tax-collection software that will ensure that business owners can easily and inexpensively comply with the tax laws implemented by a variety of State and Local agencies.

    The argument against is that if the Feds dip their resources into the process, they would be looking for ways to dip even more money out of the economy. So perhaps a better solution would involve a non-profit corporation operated by all of the participating states to collect those revenues, much in the same way that many states have combined their state Lottery systems within a company formed in agreement with the various participating states.

    The patchwork of more than 7,500 jurisdictions currently makes taxation laws almost a back-breaker for any business that wants to comply.

    Until a system can be established that allows businesses to collect taxes in a way that is economically feasible for them to do, states will continue to shoot themselves in the foot, and small business owners will continue to pay the price for the stupidity and short-sightedness of their elected officials.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *






You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title="" rel=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Please leave these two fields as-is:

Protected by Invisible Defender. Showed 403 to 4,217,016 bad guys.

css.php